The battle over television
For today’s class, I decided to abandon the textbook…for just a short while. Today’s topic in the textbook was a short piece of realistic fiction about too much television. After reading the story, it came to me…why not have students participate in a real debate so that they can learn both sides of the argument for and against children watching television.
This is a the format of the stories that students read from their textbooks.
After the reading there are basic recall questions to answer.
There are very few, if any, critical thinking or problem sovling questions to answer.
I visited the school library in hopes of finding information of some kind related to this topic so that students could come and prepare for their side of the debate…instead I discovered that the library consisted of a few shelves of only student textbooks. The computer lab seemed like the next best option, however, there is not internet connection. The computers are only for word documents. So it looked like students would not have the experience of collecting information to use in the debate, I would have to provide the information.
The school library has only student copies of the subject textbooks and old newspapers.
Mema is lucky because most schools don't have a library at all.
So yesterday I went to town to look up two articles online to print. I discovered two articles presenting arguments for and against television, however, because printing is costly, I was only able to print one article each. We were going to have to share.
For the debate, I divided the class in half. One side of the class worked on reading from the textbook using the before, during, and after reading strategies that we have been working with, while the other half worked on preparing for a debate. Since students were not too familiar with preparing for a debate I helped walk them through the article. We focused on identifying the key points for our argument and then finding data and statistics to defend the argument. After helping one side prepare, we switched and I worked with the other half of the class while the other students read from their textbook. Not the most efficient way to do things but it worked. After both sides finished preparing we talked as a class about the differences between the textbook story and the information presented in the article. We were able to begin our debate before the bell rang. Although we didn’t finish the debate, I hope that students were able to take away a few lessons from today’s class. I hope that they were able to see the importance of supporting their argument with hard facts and data that we saw in the articles and that they were able to see how reading comprehension applies to real life!